For me this article is yet another example of a loving God. He is returning his child to their eternal home, and he provides comfort at times for those who are still living a physical existence. You know, thinking out loud here, our actual existence is well documented and explained through study and results of experimentation and science. But it is completely explained when one folds in the spiritual...
From Epoch News:
Terminal Lucidity: Many Patients Experience an Unexplained Return of Mental Acuity in Their Final Days
The phenomenon is not new, and instances have been recorded in the medial literature going back to the 19th century.
Friends Read Free
Terminal Lucidity: Many Patients Experience an Unexplained Return of Mental Acuity in Their Final Days
The case study of Anna Katherina Ehmer is one of the most famous studies of terminal lucidity, a phenomenon that continues to baffle researchers.
Ms. Ehmer, known as Käthe, was a German woman born severely disabled in 1895. At six years of age, she was sent to a mental institution where she would live until she died at the age of 26.
“Käthe was among the patients with the most severe mental disabilities who have ever lived in our institution. From birth on, she was seriously retarded. She had never learned to speak a single word. She stared for hours on a particular spot, then she fidgeted for hours without a break. She gorged her food, fouled herself day and night, uttered an animal-like sound, and slept. In all the time she lived with us, we have never seen that she had taken notice of her environment even for a second,” recounted Dr. Friedrich Happich, who ran the institution.
Käthe suffered from several episodes of meningitis, which were thought to have “destroyed much of the brain tissue required for intelligent reasoning.” She also had tuberculosis, which led to the amputation of her leg and was the eventual cause of her death. She had never spoken a single word.
But, as she lay dying, something unexpected happened. She began singing to herself.
She sang—clearly and in perfect German—a funeral hymn. She sang to herself for a full half hour until she passed away.
Dr. Happich recounted the following scene at Kathe’s deathbed:
“One day I was called by one of our physicians, who is respected both as a scientist and a psychiatrist. He said: ‘Come immediately to Käthe, she is dying!’
“When we entered the room together, we did not believe our eyes and ears. Käthe, who had never spoken a single word, being entirely mentally disabled from birth on, sang dying songs to herself. Specifically, she sang over and over again ‘Where does the soul find its home, its peace? Peace, peace, heavenly peace!’ For half an hour she sang. Her face, up to then so stultified, was transfigured and spiritualized. Then, she quietly passed away. Like myself and the nurse who had cared for her, the physician had tears in his eyes.”
Terminal lucidity is most often seen in dementia patients right before they die. They have a brief period of lucidity where they come “back to life” and regain the qualities that make them who they are—or were before the onset of the disease.
This lucidity can include the ability to recall memories that were thought lost to a disease that slowly destroys the brain, as well as the ability to communicate—something that may long ago have disappeared as a consequence of their illness.
The phenomenon is not unique to those with dementia and happens in patients with other conditions such as severe psychiatric conditions, brain disorders, tumors, meningitis, brain abscesses, strokes, and brain injuries, as well as patients in comas who may wake up shortly before dying.
In 2009, German biologist Michael Nahm defined the term terminal lucidity in an article in the Journal of Near-Death Studies as: “The (re-) emergence of normal or unusually enhanced mental abilities in dull, unconscious, or mentally ill patients shortly before death, including considerable elevation of mood and spiritual affectation, or the ability to speak in a previously unusual spiritualized and elated manner.”
Paradoxical lucidity is a broader term that refers to the same phenomenon—a patient’s sudden return to mental clarity and the ability to speak and remember—and can happen anytime, not just before death. Some experts suggest paradoxical lucidity should only refer to those with severe neurodegenerative conditions that often render them non-communicative.
Experiences During Terminal Lucidity
A wide range of things can happen during these episodes of clarity, but there are some characteristics that those who experience terminal lucidity share. According to All American Hospice, the following are common among patients:
Requesting their favorite food or object
Recognizing or looking for a friend or family member
Being in a good mood and becoming more verbal
Reminiscing about good times when they were young
Looking for or talking to deceased people, pets, or religious figures
Having unexplained sensory experiences like seeing lights or hearing sounds
Talking about traveling or preparing to travel alone
Predicting the exact time of death
Other common experiences are improvement of physical symptoms, like pain, speaking clearly and coherently, answering questions from others, remembering things previously thought forgotten, getting up and walking around, and engaging in activities like singing.
Terminal Lucidity Case Studies
A review authored by Mr. Nahm and Dr. Bruce Greyson, et al., collected case reports of terminal lucidity and its occurrence in patients with a variety of conditions.
In a case from 1990, a five-year-old boy dying of a malignant brain tumor had been in a coma for three weeks. During this period, his family members had remained at his bedside. Eventually, upon advice from their minister, the family told their comatose son that although they would miss him, he had their permission to die.
“Suddenly and unexpectedly, the boy regained consciousness, thanked the family for letting him go, and told them he would be dying soon.” He died the next day. (Morse and Perry, 1990)
In another case, a young man was dying of cancer that had spread from his lungs to his brain. At the end of his life, brain scans found that the tumors had destroyed and replaced almost all of his brain tissue, and in the days before he died, he lost the ability to move or speak. However, his wife and a nurse observed that an hour before he died, he “woke up,” said goodbye to his family, and spoke with them for about five minutes before he lost consciousness and died. (Haig, 2007)
A third case involves an 81-year-old woman with Alzheimer’s who had been living in a retirement home in Iceland. Members of her family took turns visiting her even though she hadn’t recognized any of them or spoken for a year. One day, her son Lydur was sitting at her bedside when she suddenly sat up, looked at him directly in the face, and said:
“My Lydur, I am going to recite a verse to you.”
According to her son, she then very clearly recited the following verse, which he thought particularly appropriate to her situation (translated):
“Oh, father of light, be adored.
Life and health you gave to me,
My father and my mother.
Now I sit up, for the sun is shining.
You send your light in to me.
Oh, God, how good you are.”
After reciting the verse, the woman laid back down and was unresponsive—remaining this way until she died a month later.
Her son wrote down the verse thinking it was his mother’s original words, but later discovered it was the first stanza from an Icelandic poem.
Terminal lucidity is not a new phenomenon, and instances have been recorded in the medical literature since the 19th century.
A study examining cases of terminal lucidity going as far back as 1826 found that 84 percent of those who experienced this brief period of lucidity died within a week, and 43 percent of those died within 24 hours. But, some episodes can emerge up to six months before death.
One study researching paradoxical lucidity was published in Alzheimer’s and Dementia using a sample of 49 patients—many of whom had dementia. The study found that 43 percent of patients experienced paradoxical lucidity a few hours before death. Forty-one percent had the experience two to seven days before, and ten percent of the cases happened eight to 30 days before dying.
The same study cites that other researchers found that paradoxical lucidity in dementia patients typically happens within one to two days before the patients die.
There is also a wide range of variation in how long the episodes last. Another referenced study of 38 cases who experienced lucid episodes found that 5 percent lasted several days, 11 percent lasted one day, 29 percent lasted several hours, 24 percent lasted between 30 and 60 minutes, 16 percent lasted 10-30 minutes, and 3 percent of the episodes lasted less than ten minutes.
Some scientists have wondered if certain situations or stimuli may trigger these lucid episodes. Although the conditions in which these lucid episodes occur vary, having family members present and playing music that is familiar or meaningful to the patient are both relatively common.
These episodes are also witnessed by caregivers, nurses, doctors, and hospice and palliative care workers who care for terminally ill patients.
A study of end-of-life experiences found that seven out of ten caregivers in a nursing home said that in the last five years, they had observed patients with dementia and confusion become lucid a few days before they died.
Mysterious Causes
Scientists are still determining what causes terminal lucidity, and the phenomenon is difficult to study because of its unpredictable and transient nature. Studying these lucid episodes during their brief occurrence would also be considered unethical—taking away precious time patients could use to reconnect with their loved ones.
A 2009 report by Mr. Nahm and Dr. Greyson states that historically, physicians studying the phenomenon thought the cause was changes in brain physiology as the patient was dying. However, the authors say these conclusions are “rather general and seem inadequate from a modern medical perspective.”
Many questions remain about terminal lucidity and its causes.
All American Hospice states that many “question whether it’s real, spiritual, or just a supernatural experience,” writing that some believe it may be spiritual because the patient “wakes up” to complete their unfinished work, like saying goodbye, making their last wishes known, or seeing someone for the last time.
One study theorized that terminal lucidity may be physical due to brain changes right before death.
An article by Yen Ying Lim, an associate professor at the Turner Institute for Brain and Mental Health, and Diny Thomson, a doctoral candidate in clinical neuropsychology and a provisional psychologist—both from Monash University—said that the explanations extend beyond science: “These moments of mental clarity may be a way for the dying person to say final goodbyes, gain closure before death, and reconnect with family and friends. Some believe episodes of terminal lucidity are representative of the person connecting with an afterlife.”
Helping Loved Ones Cope
For those who witness these lucid episodes, they can be either a positive or stressful experience—and sometimes both. One study published in 2022 asked caregivers to appraise their experiences of these episodes in patients with late-stage Alzheimer’s and related dementias. Seventy-two percent reported them to be “quite a bit or very positive,” 17 percent said they were stressful, and 10 percent said they were a combination of the two.
Terminal lucidity can be stressful and confusing for some family members who may think it is a sign that their loved one is recovering and demand a change in care to accommodate this new situation—causing considerable emotional turmoil for family members, friends, and staff who care for the patient.
The article by Yen Ying Lim and Diny Thomson from Monash University referenced above, discusses terminal lucidity in those with dementia, and the importance of people knowing about the condition.
“Being aware of terminal lucidity can help loved ones understand it is part of the dying process, acknowledge the person with dementia will not recover, and allow them to make the most of the time they have with the lucid person,” they said.
For scientists, terminal lucidity represents an opportunity to reevaluate our understanding of the brain and the perception that the cognitive losses that characterize Alzheimer’s and other dementias are inevitable and irreversible.
For families, these brief episodes of lucidity can be a wonderful gift, allowing the sick person to say goodbye, reconnect with their family and friends, communicate their last wishes, and be an opportunity to ask for or give forgiveness. For loved ones of patients with severe dementia who may not have had any communication with them for many years, this can be a very healing experience for everyone involved and a beautiful way to say goodbye.
